top of page
Search

Exercise Should Be Prescribed According to the Goal

Dr Michael Elliott MSc, D.C., CFMP.
Nov 12
3 min read

Two people can complete the same workout and need very different things from it. One wants to rebuild strength. Another wants to improve endurance. A third wants to get out of a chair and manage the stairs with greater confidence.

“Exercise more” leaves the most useful question unanswered: What are we trying to improve?

Exercise produces overlapping benefits, but its type, intensity, volume and progression influence the adaptations we develop. A useful prescription begins with the desired outcome and the person's current capacity.

General health provides a foundation

World Health Organization guidance recommends that adults accumulate 150–300 minutes of moderate aerobic activity, or 75–150 minutes of vigorous activity, each week, together with muscle-strengthening activity on at least two days.[2]

These are population-level targets. Someone who is inactive, recovering from illness or managing substantial limitations may need to begin with much less and build gradually.

For a specific goal, the programme needs further detail.

Strength, muscle size and power are different outcomes

Strength is the ability to produce force. Muscle growth concerns muscle size. Power involves producing force quickly. They are related, but training can emphasise each differently.

The American College of Sports Medicine's 2026 position stand supports progressive resistance training and adjusting the prescription to the goal. Heavier loads can favour maximal strength, while higher weekly training volume can favour muscle growth. Power training places particular emphasis on the speed of the lifting phase with an appropriate load.[3]

Those findings guide programming; they are not a starting prescription for every patient. Technique, experience, symptoms and recovery capacity determine what is appropriate now.

Endurance needs sustained practice

For someone wanting to walk further, cycle more comfortably or improve aerobic fitness, regular aerobic activity needs a central place in the plan. Walking, cycling, swimming and other accessible options can provide that stimulus.

The initial prescription should match current capacity. A short, repeatable session may be the right starting point. Duration, frequency or intensity can then progress according to response. Hard intervals are one option for suitable people, rather than a requirement for everyone.

Daily function deserves its own goals

For an older adult, the meaningful outcome may be carrying shopping, rising from a chair or negotiating steps. Strength and aerobic fitness matter, but the programme may also need balance and practice of the relevant tasks. WHO guidance specifically includes multicomponent activity emphasising balance and strength for older adults.[2]

We should measure whether those tasks become easier, rather than relying only on body weight or calories recorded by a watch.

For fat-loss goals, exercise should sit within a broader nutrition and health plan. Progress can include improved fitness and strength even when scale weight changes slowly. For rehabilitation, the exercise choice and progression must also account for the diagnosis and symptom response.

Prescribe, observe and adjust

A useful exercise prescription records the goal, activity, frequency, intensity, duration or sets and repetitions, and the intended progression. It also makes room for preference: an effective activity has greater practical value when someone can access and sustain it.

Review the outcome that prompted the prescription. Is strength improving? Can the person walk further? Are daily tasks easier? Is recovery adequate?

Sweat, soreness and exhaustion cannot answer all of those questions. The test is whether the programme is producing a useful adaptation at a tolerable cost.

Before changing your next workout, decide what you want it to help you do.

 
 
bottom of page