top of page
Search

When Should You Change a Strategy That's Not Working?

Dr Michael Elliott MSc, D.C., CFMP.
3 days ago
3 min read

Dr D Michael Elliott MSc, D.C., CFMP

You have given a health strategy your time, effort and perhaps money. You expected improvement, but the result has been disappointing. Should you persist, adjust the plan or try something else?

The decision begins with a careful review of the goal, the strategy, the time allowed and the response. Disappointing progress is useful information, provided you examine what it means.

Check safety first

New or worsening symptoms, significant adverse effects or deterioration in daily function can justify review before the planned date.

Do not assume that feeling worse is evidence of “detoxification”, “die-off” or a treatment beginning to work. Symptoms need an explanation appropriate to the intervention and your circumstances.

Seek prompt clinical advice when a treatment appears to be causing harm. Prescribed medicines may need supervised adjustment or gradual withdrawal, so do not change them independently.

Make sure the strategy matches the goal

An intervention can be useful while doing little for the particular outcome you want.

A relaxation routine may help you manage stress but contribute little to a strength goal. A general exercise programme may improve wellbeing while needing modification to address a specific functional limitation.

Return to the original question: what was this strategy expected to change, and what evidence supported that expectation? If the link is weak, greater effort may not solve the problem.

Check whether the plan was workable

A strategy that was rarely carried out has not received the same trial as one followed consistently. That observation should lead to a practical discussion.

Was the plan too complex? Did it require time you did not have? Was the food unaffordable, the exercise painful or the schedule incompatible with work?

Changing the delivery can be more useful than abandoning the underlying approach. A shorter session, simpler meal plan or clearer reminder may make consistency possible. Behaviour-change guidance encourages identifying roadblocks and adapting plans around them.[1]

A plan that repeatedly fails to fit your life needs redesign. That is a feature of the plan to address, not a verdict on your character.

Allow an appropriate period to assess response

Some changes can be assessed relatively quickly. Others require sustained practice or a clinician-defined follow-up interval. There is no universal number of weeks that fairly tests every intervention.

Ask what a reasonable early response should look like, when the main outcome can be assessed and what should trigger earlier review.

Avoid extending the trial indefinitely simply because improvement remains theoretically possible. Set a review point that reflects the evidence and the clinical situation.

Check how you are measuring success

A strategy can appear ineffective when the measurement misses its intended benefit. If your goal is improved function, a scale reading alone may provide little useful information. Consider relevant symptoms, ability and performance alongside appropriate clinical measures.

The opposite also matters. A favourable number does not automatically mean that the strategy has improved your health or daily life.

Review the overall benefit, adverse effects, inconvenience and cost. Where outcomes fluctuate, compare trends and context rather than selecting the best or worst day.

Choose the smallest useful adjustment

When the approach remains plausible and safe, a focused adjustment can make the next review more informative. You might change the exercise progression, simplify the routine or ask your clinician to review administration, dose or interactions.

Changing several things simultaneously makes it harder to understand the next result. However, necessary clinical care takes priority over keeping a plan unchanged.

If an adequately delivered strategy has produced no worthwhile benefit within an appropriate period, reconsider it. Time and money already spent do not create a reason to keep spending them.

Reassess the explanation when needed

Persistent difficulty can signal that the original explanation was incomplete. Symptoms may have another cause, or an unrecognised barrier may be limiting progress.

Repeatedly adding interventions can postpone that reassessment. A focused clinical review may be more useful than another supplement, test or programme.

At your next review, choose a clear next step: continue, simplify, make a specific adjustment, finish the strategy with appropriate guidance or investigate further. Record why you made that decision and when you will review again.

Source

 
 
bottom of page